Israeli
officials said they would take in only two women and a teenager for
humanitarian reasons and that the rest of the group would be removed
from the fence area and taken to Cairo by Egyptian authorities.
"It
is important that everyone understands that Israel is no longer a
destination for infiltrators," Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu
said in a statement.
Government officials said the refugees
agreed to the arrangement, but representatives for the group could not
be reached to verify the statement. The Israeli military has prevented
aid groups and activists from reaching the Eritreans to provide food,
medical care and legal assistance.
Activists criticized the
arrangement, saying that refugees previously returned to Egypt had been
mistreated by authorities there.
Earlier in the day, the Israeli
human rights group We Are Refugees petitioned the Supreme Court to order
the Israeli government to assist all of the refugees, contending that
leaving them at the fence was a violation of international law and
Israel's obligation as a signatory to the U.N. refugee convention.
Aid
groups say the Eritreans had run out of food and water, were suffering
under the desert sun and were afraid to turn back to Egypt because of
Bedouin gangs of human traffickers in the Sinai who routinely rob,
kidnap and kill African refugees trying to make their way to Israel to
start new lives.
"These people are suffering behind a fence," said
Orit Marom, a coordinator for the Tel Aviv-based Aid Organization for
Refugees and Asylum Seekers in Israel. "But Israel does not let them in.
It's crazy. It reminds [the Jewish people] of a very bad period in our
own history."
Government officials refused to allow in the entire
group, saying they were worried about setting a precedent that would
encourage other African refugees to attempt to enter Israel. Since 2006,
more than 60,000 African refugees, mostly from Eritrea and Sudan, have
flooded into Israel via the Sinai peninsula, according to the
government.
Initially the military said it gave the Eritreans only
water, but government attorneys told the court Thursday — before the
reported agreement was reached — that authorities would start providing
food.
William Tall, senior protection officer in Israel with the
Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, called
Israel's actions "exaggerated and irrational."
Tall noted that
even though the refugees were blocked by the fence, Israel had
acknowledged that the group was on Israeli territory because the fence
was built on Israel's side of the border.
 |
| An Israeli soldier hands water to one of the African refugees stranded at… (Yehuda Lahiani) |
"They are on Israeli territory and asking for asylum," Tall said.
"It's absolutely clear that Israel has an obligation to review their
asylum claims."
The government disagreed, saying it has no legal
obligation because under international practice and precedent, the fence
should be considered the de facto border in this situation.
"Technically
the land may be sovereign Israeli territory, but legally the fence
constitutes the border," said Foreign Ministry spokesman Yigal Palmor.
He said Israel does not want to set a precedent under which it assists all refugees who make it to the fence.
"Where does it stop?" he asked. "You have to draw the line somewhere. Otherwise the fence is meaningless."
The
standoff is the latest controversy in Israel's effort to cope with a
surge in African refugees, who view Israel as the closest wealthy and
democratic nation they can reach on foot.
Israeli Interior
Minister Eli Yishai this summer began deporting hundreds of South
Sudanese who fled violence in their homeland. He also ordered the
detention of hundreds of others.
Israeli officials say the
refugees, along with migrant workers and other foreigners, pose a threat
to the nation's economy and Jewish majority. Many foreigners in recent
months have been subjected to a violent backlash, including beatings and
firebombs thrown at their homes.
Israel also sped up construction
of the 150-mile fence along the Egyptian border. The crackdown appears
to have slowed the influx. The number of refugees crossing the border
fell from 2,000 a month at its peak last year to 200 in August, the
government says.